I don't know about you but I've always loved a fresh homemade carrot cake. Nothing beats it. When I go to restaurants and I see they have it on their menu and I usually will order a slice but am always disappoitned because it isn't fresh, it's hard and tasteless.
So now I make my own. It isn't hard. It isn't tedious either. It's just like making a regular cake. Seriously. You can make it gourmet by spicing up the decorations like piping on your own colored carrots or adding swirls but that just adds extra time and takes away from eating the cake that much sooner.
So, here we go. How to make a TASTY Homemade Carrot Cake (including tons of pictures):
This recipe is from a lady I work with. She's had it in her family for years. She knows how much I love to cook and bake so she gave it to me. It's really good. I used Pioneer Woman's recipe for frosting though...because it makes more and it's a butter/cream cheese mixture.
Here are the recipes:
I saw another blogger do this on her site and I thought, that's clever. Use an off-set picture of the food and use the "white space" to put the recipe. Clever!
So, anyway, back to the purpose of this post. Making carrot cake.
First thing. Pre-heat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
Just thought I'd add this picture because nobody posts pictures of their oven. LOL
Next, you are going to want to get your pans ready. I like to make a tall round cake instead of a sheet cake...because it looks cool and seems more exciting than a sheet cake but you can just do a sheet cake if you like, no need to get crazy like me.
I spray pam on each 9" round pan. Make sure to get all of the bottom and sides. Then I take one spoonful of regular flour and drop it in the middle then just tilt and tap the pan to move around the flour to coat all of the bottom and sides. Don't worry if you don't get all the way up the sides. It's okay. Your main priority is the bottom so the cake doesn't stick to the pan.
Dump out any excess flour when the pan is coated.
Now you need to grate your carrots. You need about 3 cups. I do this first so I have the carrots ready to put in after I mix the wet and dry ingredients together. I like to be prepared. I'm a bit anal. I'm an accountant by trade...so there you go.
I like to use the largest grater on my rectangular grater. It's easier to grate than the smaller sizes plus the size of the carrots coming out is a bit larger which makes the cake at the end have more visible orange color. Don't worry, you won't bite into a huge chunk of carrot. They will bake down in the oven.
To grate carrots and not shave off your knuckle, which I've almost done. Yeah, I bled all over the place. It wasn't fun. There was a lot of swearing involved.
Anyways, what I've found that works best for me is to cut off the top part of the carrot (about a 1/2 inch) and some of the smallest part of the root on the bottom (1/2 inch to an inch depending on how thick the carrot is). Then I cut the carrot in half and grate each part separately.
I like this approach because the carrot starts off big at the top and tapers down to a much smaller size. So if you split this up and take the larger part and grate it then take the smaller part and grate it it's easier to hold. Because it's smaller it's less likely to break while you grate because it'll fit nicely in your hand.
I also make sure not to grate too far down on the carrot because the closer you get to your knuckles the more likely it'll be for you to grate off a piece of your knuckle.
Okay, enough of that.
Here are the ingredients other than the cake's namesake, Carrots. (p.s. You don't have to use the exact ingredients I do because some of them are more expensive than regular ingredients and this economy is rough for everyone. I just like to show exactly what I use.)
Plain granulated sugar, regular flour (not bread flour), baking soda (fresh otherwise the recipe won't turn out), cinnamon (good Vietnamese cinnamon from Lunds and Byerly's), some fine Himalayan pink sea salt (I have been using this lately as it is organic and is said to be one of the purest salts there is plus I think sea salt as opposed to regular salt gives more flavor), vegetable oil, eggs (organic...because that's what I picked up at the grocery store), carrots (organic), Hope butter (because it's the BEST! handmade by a small creamery in Hope, MN...and because it's the best it isn't as cheap as regular butter but well worth it in results), cream cheese, Madagascar Bourban Vanilla Bean Paste (again the best, such good flavor plus you can see the vanilla bean specks in the frosting) and some chopped pecans (so tasty and organic.
I chopped about 1 cup of pecans in my manual food processor (I'm saving for the real deal but the one I want is $200 or more). Just chop them somewhat finely. They are going in your frosting. You can leave these out too if you don't like or are allergic to nuts. The cake is still good. :)
You can use a food chopper or cut them with a knife by hand but I like this way because it's the fastest and easiest and least messy.
Okay, now that we have the oven pre-heated, the pans buttered and floured, the carrots grated and the pecans chopped we are ready to go.
We are going to start with the dry ingredients first. We separate the dry and wet because we want to mix them evenly by themselves then add them together. That's the main goal in baking. Even distribution of ingredients.
First we sift the first five ingredients together: flour, sugar, baking soda, cinnamon and salt.
2 cups flour
2 cups sugar
2 tsp. baking soda
2 tsp. cinnamon...ahhh....the smell of this is divine and gives the cake it's slightly darker color.
and 1 tsp. of the pink sea salt.
Now give it a stir with a whisk. Using a whisk makes it easy to get the ingredients mixed together evenly. You can use a spatula but I find it's easier to get a more even distribution with a whisk. That's what you want. Even distribution. This only takes a sec.
This is what it looks like when you're done. All mixed nicely together. You can't really see the 5 different items you just mixed.
Now dump the dry ingredients in the mixer bowl.
Now turn your mixer on beat. Start off slow and add the 1 1/2 cups of oil in slowly so it mixes evenly. Again, even distribution. Once you've got a little liquid in the mixture, turn up the beater one notch and keep adding the oil.
The reason you don't start the beater off higher is because if you did this the dry mixture would fly all over the place. I've done this. Not pretty. Makes a big mess. So start slow then gradually crank it one notch.
Mixing away.
Now, this is mixed well, you won't have to mix it forever. It just needs to be neatly combined and a tad bit chunky. It'll smooth out when we start adding the eggs. Here, take a peek at the mixture now.
Now, add each egg, one at a time until all 4 eggs are added. You want to mix each egg in thoroughly before the next egg is added. You want to do this to make sure they are evenly distributed.
You can tell it's evenly distributed because you don't see any of the egg yolk. It will slightly yellow the mixture and will be a smooth color. No yellow streaks.
This is how it looks after you've added all 4 eggs. Smooth and evenly colored.
Look at that. Makes you want to just stick a finger under that beater and sneak a taste doesn't it? Go on, it's okay. I usually do just to make sure it doesn't taste funky. Really, if it tastes funky you've got an ingredient problem. :)
Now add in your grated carrots and beat together. Just let it mix together on the beat setting. Your objective is to just mix it evenly together. If it's not even some portions of the cake won't have any carrot flavor or texture and some will have too much.
This is the cake batter in all its gloriousness. Sorry that was a bit dramatic but it looks luscious doesn't it?
Now, pour your batter evenly into each of the two pans or into the single rectangular pan. In order to get them even you just kind of have to eye-ball it. That's what I do. I pour a little bit into the first pan, then some into the next, then go back to the first and do it again.
I do this so that I don't dump too much into the first one then realize it was too much and have a hard time scooping out the batter from the first into the second.
See, that's about even. Even if they aren't perfect, don't worry, nobody will notice anyway. They'll be too busy stuffing this cake into their mouths as fast as they can.
Bake in the oven for about 35 minutes or so. You can tell when they are done because the tops will be slightly brown and if you push your finger lightly down in the middle it should fluff right back up. If it doesn't fluff back up then that means your cake is still doughy and needs to cook longer.
If you cook it too long it'll be very brown on top and slightly hard. To avoid this just keep an eye on the cake. I usually set my timer on 30 minutes, check it then put the timer on for a couple minutes then check it again. That usually works for me.
Here's what the final looks like. Isn't this beautiful? Notice how the edges are slighly browned and slightly pulled away from the edge. The middle is slightly light. This is what you want.
Let the pans cool on a rack until they are cool. In Minnesota I have an advantage. I put these bad boys out in my back porch where it is cold and they cool in about 15 minutes. Nice.
Now you are going to want to get these cakes out of the pans without breaking them. Easy peasy lemon squeezy.
All you do is take one pan at a time and cover with the wire rack. Put one hand on the top and one on the bottom (so one hand on the rack and one on the bottom of the pan) and quickly flip over. If the cake doesn't fall out easily just give the bottom of the pan a couple of taps. This always works for me.
Take the pan off and flip your cake back over by just putting your whole hand over the cake, your other hand on the rack and flip it. It should be cool enough now that it won't fall apart when you do this. Wahlah!
Repeat with the other cake.
You can arrange them on your cake pedestal once you get your frosting done. I'm just sayin' you have to put this cake on a pedestal. It's that good. Really. It is and we haven't even gotten to the frosting yet.
Now make your frosting...um...sorry about no pictures. I was in such a hurry to get this done and eat it that I neglected the frosting picture portion of this post. Dang it. Sorry.
All you do for the frosting is cream together 1 stick of softened butter and 1 8 oz. package of softened cream cheese. Soften as in just let it sit out on the counter while you're making the cake. That should be plenty of time for it to soften up for you.
When I cream these two items together I start off slow then gradually increase the mixer spead. This works well because you don't overwhelm your mixer right off the bat. Mine doesn't have much horse power so I don't want to wreck it by going max speed right off the bat.
Then once mixed together and once again, evenly distributed, add the powdered sugar and the vanilla. Make sure you start slow otherwise your powdered sugar will fly all over the place. It will. Your kids might get a kick out of a huge tornado of powdered sugar all of the place but you won't. It's a mess.
So beat slowly then gradually get faster as the mixture incorporates together. I usually mix for awhile, stop, taste it, if it seems grainy or the flavor seems too buttery I keep mixing or add a bit more of powdered sugar. It should have a firm but smooth consistency when you are done. Easily spreadable but not liquidy.
Then add the chopped pecans and beat together until evenly distributed.
Now put your first cake layer down, put a 1/4 to a 1/2 cup of frosting down and spread with an offset spatula. Don't spread to the edge of the round cake or it'll squeeze out onto your edges when you put down the next layer.
Add your next layer and spread the frosting on top and along the sides. It doesn't have to be perfect. No one will care. They'll be too busy stuffing their face.
Eat!
Recent Comments